Jan 13 2010

What Happens After 2011?

Published by at 9:50 am under Afghanistan,Canada,Canadian Forces

A decision to walk away from an unfinished war, with all its attendant risks to national interests and dispiriting connotations of retreat and forsaken sacrifices, is only slightly less important than was the decision to enter it in the first place. A decision to go to war or to withdraw ought to be the finale, not the beginning, of a detailed analysis of the consequences in either case.

What do Canadians want for Afghanistan post-2011 and what are we willing to do to achieve it? It’s long past time for Canadians to start talking about these questions.

For example, does a pullout embolden the Taliban and it’s allies, putting Canadians at more risk down the line? What kind of message does it send to our allies if we abandon the field? Why are we talking about pulling everything to meet an arbitrary deadline just when the mission is showing signs of success?

Forget troops-in, troops-out. What does Canada want to achieve? And do we really want to leave our accomplishments thus far to help the Afghan people to the tender mercies of the Taliban, while the Afghan National Army is only now beginning to get to it’s feet as an effective arm of the Afghan government?

These questions can’t be ignored any longer. And it’s long past time that the leaders of the various political parties started showing some leadership on this file.

[Slashdot] [Digg] [Reddit] [del.icio.us] [Facebook] [Technorati] [Google] [StumbleUpon]

One response so far

One Response to “What Happens After 2011?”

  1. Dmorrison 13 Jan 2010 at 4:19 pm

    I doubt the NATO forces will pull out of Afghanistan completely in 2011. It’s more likely they’ll scale back, and do a bunch of photo-ops of troops returning home to their joyful families.

    They’ll have to keep a fairly substantial police force over there, or lose the whole Country to various local factions,among whom will be the Taliban.

    Michael Yon says it’s a hundred year deal, I’m sure the politicians are well aware of that fact. They’ll just have to figure out a way to get the story the hell off the front pages,so that every soldier KIA isn’t a blow against the serving government.

    Maybe it’s time for Countries to start hiring mercenaries, and leave our troops and the Media at home.

Trackback URI | Comments RSS

Leave a Reply